Everton v Manchester City 1958/59 Posted on May 23, 2012 by boswell — No Comments ↓ EVERTON 1 CITY 3 League Division 1 31st January 1959 attendance 43,360 scorers City Barlow Everton ??? Ref F Gerrard City Trautmann, Leivers, Horridge, Phoenix, Ewing, Barnes, Hannah, Johnstone, McAdams Barlow, Sambrook