Everton v Manchester City 1957/58 Posted on June 16, 2012 by boswell — No Comments ↓ EVERTON 2 CITY 5 League Division 1 19th April 1958 attendance 38,000 scorers City Hart 2, Hayes, Sambrook, Barnes Everton ??? Ref C Sant City Trautmann, Branagan, Sear, Barnes, Leivers, Warhurst, Fagan, Barlow, Hart, Hayes, Sambrook